false
Catalog
2021 AOSSM-AANA Combined Annual Meeting Recordings
Investigating the Chronology of Meniscus Root Tear ...
Investigating the Chronology of Meniscus Root Tears: Do Medial Meniscus Posterior Root Tears Cause Extrusion or the Other Way Around?
Back to course
[Please upgrade your browser to play this video content]
Video Transcription
Functionally, they're equivalent to total meniscectomy with loss of hoop stress and increased peak contact forces. The menisciotibial ligament, or MT ligament, originates at the posterior medial aspect of the tibia, and it anchors the posterior body and horn of the meniscus. Recently, we've been learning more about its biomechanical role, namely that it serves in meniscus stabilization, centralization, and most importantly, as a restraint to extrusion. Extrusion has been associated with posterior medial meniscus root tears and the subsequent and rapid osteoarthritis that oftentimes follows them. Along with this recent recognition of extrusion in the absence of meniscus tear, we've also noticed that root repair does not always correct the extrusion. Therefore, extrusion is likely due to additional factors other than just the root attachment itself. Therefore, the purpose of our study was to understand the association between MT ligaments, the medial meniscus extrusion, and subsequent root tears. In doing so, we hope to determine the progression and ideology of meniscus extrusion over time. We reviewed serial MRIs from 2010 to 2020 at a single academic institution. Inclusion criteria consisted of two or more MRIs with at least one demonstrating extrusion and one demonstrating a root tear. Of note, this was independent of the relative timing of the above two factors. In terms of exclusion criteria, we excluded patients with prior knee surgery or patients that had an intervention between their MRIs. All of our MRIs were performed on 1.5 to three Tesla institutional scanners as per a standardized institutional protocol. They're analyzed independently by two board-certified MSK radiologists. And in terms of outcomes, we looked at extrusion, MT ligament status, and the presence of a root tear. Overall, we looked at 27 root tears in 26 patients. Their average age was 56. Average follow-up was two years. And they had a median of two MRIs, but some patients had three or four MRIs. In terms of conversion to a root tear, this occurred at a mean of 1.7 years after the patient's initial MRI. What I'd really like to highlight of our results is that MT ligament disruption, as well as extrusion, was present on MRI prior to the MRI that then demonstrated root tear for every single patient. This is an example case right here. At time zero, there's MT ligament edema, but the root is intact. Four months later, the patient had continued pain, had a repeat MRI. Here there's MT ligament attenuation. Now there's meniscus extrusion, and there is partial root tearing, but some fibers remain in continuity. Eight months later, there's a repeat MRI. At this point, the MT ligament is completely disrupted. The root is completely torn. The meniscus has displaced. At final follow-up, extrusion progressed in 96% of knees. Namely, all knees had extrusion pre-tear at an average of 3.3 millimeters. Post-tear, this increased to 5.5 millimeters. And for those patients with three or four MRIs, this increased to 5.8 millimeters at the time of final follow-up. We also noted a modified outer ridge grade progression. Namely, medial femoral condyle ICRS, sorry, outer bridge grade went from 2.4 to 3.5, whereas medial tibial plateau outer bridge grade went from 1.6 to 3.0, both of these being statistically significant. Additionally, and noteworthily, nine patients, or a third of the cohort, converted to arthroplasty at a mean of three years after their initial MRI, or one and a half to two years after their root tear. Given our findings, we proposed the following root tear chronology. Initially, patients have empty ligament stress and attenuation. As the empty ligament attenuates and stretches, there's early extrusion. Subsequently, there's a medial meniscus post-tear root tear and increasing extrusion, as now both the empty ligament and the root are gone in terms of resisting extrusion. And finally, there's the rapid onset of osteoarthritis. In terms of our discussion, there's currently a positive literature on the chronologic etiology of root tears. We believe our study is novel in its inclusion of two or more serial MRIs, and it suggests that extrusion and empty ligament disruption predisposes to root tears. This also aligns with previous studies which have demonstrated extrusion without root tear. Again, I'd like to highlight that all patients had empty ligament disruption prior to their root tear. This is important as isolated root repair does not fully correct meniscus extrusion, and this serves a potential role of empty ligament repair or meniscus centralization at the time of root repair. In conclusion, all patients demonstrated empty ligament disruption and meniscus extrusion prior to medial meniscus post-tear root tear. Our findings suggest empty ligament disruption and extrusion represent early predisposing events to meniscus root tear, and furthermore, this provides a possible explanation as to why extrusion is not corrected with isolated medial meniscus root repair. Thank you for your time and attention. Thank you.
Video Summary
The video discusses the biomechanical role of the menisciotibial (MT) ligament and its association with meniscus extrusion and subsequent root tears. The study reviewed serial MRIs from 2010 to 2020, focusing on patients with extrusion and root tears. The results showed that MT ligament disruption and extrusion were present prior to root tear in all patients. Extrusion progressed in 96% of knees, and there was a modified outer ridge grade progression. About a third of the patients eventually underwent arthroplasty. The study suggests that MT ligament disruption and extrusion are early predisposing events to meniscus root tear, highlighting the importance of addressing these factors in treatment. The summary is based on a video transcript and no credits are mentioned.
Asset Caption
Mario Hevesi, MD
Keywords
biomechanical role
menisciotibial ligament
meniscus extrusion
root tears
arthroplasty
×
Please select your language
1
English