The Journal Reviewers' Workshop from the July 2024 AOSSM Annual Meeting-The Journal Reviewers' Workshop from the 2024 AOSSM Annual Meeting

Video Transcription

Video Summary

The video transcript details a reviewers' workshop aimed at enhancing the skills of reviewers for the American Journal of Sports Medicine (AJSM). Two key speakers, Jim Carey and Derek Davis, presented on different aspects of manuscript reviews, specifically focusing on the use of statistical graphics and anatomic imaging in sports medicine literature.<br /><br />Jim Carey addressed the importance of understanding statistical graphics, such as flow diagrams, box-and-whisker plots, and Kaplan-Meier curves. He stressed the necessity of using conventional formats for data depiction to ensure familiarity and ease of comprehension for readers. Carey illustrated how these graphical tools can effectively display data variation and uncertainty, using examples from sports medicine literature, such as studies on cartilage repair and ACL reconstruction. He warned against the pitfalls of relying solely on textual data, advocating for visual aids that can provide a clearer and more immediate understanding.<br /><br />Derek Davis, a radiologist and professor, discussed the intricacies of anatomic imaging in manuscripts. He emphasized the importance of accurately describing imaging protocols and methodologies to ensure reproducibility and validity. Davis recommended that study participants should receive consistent imaging protocols and highlighted the need for independent and blinded image analysis. He also addressed frequently encountered challenges, such as the quality of imaging figures and the necessity for clear and accurate figure legends. Additionally, he underscored the need to evaluate the background of the individuals performing the image analyses, noting that expertise levels can significantly impact the validity of the findings.<br /><br />Overall, the workshop aimed to enhance reviewers' abilities by providing them with specific insights and tools to critically assess and improve the quality of sports medicine manuscripts.

Keywords

reviewers' workshop

American Journal of Sports Medicine

AJSM

Jim Carey

Derek Davis

statistical graphics

anatomic imaging

manuscript reviews

sports medicine literature

data visualization