false
Home
AOSSM 2022 Annual Meeting Recordings - no CME
Q & A: Hip II (Outside the Joint)
Q & A: Hip II (Outside the Joint)
Back to course
[Please upgrade your browser to play this video content]
Video Transcription
And then if anybody has any burning questions, feel free to come up to the mic as well if you guys wanna put a mic out. So I guess let's start with Dr. Browning on the study on gluteus repairs. Maybe if you can comment on, it appears that it's harder for these patients to reach PAS than MCID, so maybe they get better but not as good. And a related question from the audience, what's a realistic expectation for strength gains and time to adequate strength in those things after the surgery? This is working? Okay, so there's two questions there. So one was, why are patients achieving MCID at a higher rate than achieving PAS? And then the other one is, what is a reasonable expectation for improvement in strength? Yeah. Okay, so I can start with the MCID and PAS. It's fairly consistent with the rest of the literature in these patient populations that the patients are more likely to achieve MCID than PAS, as it seems that the threshold is a little bit lower for achievement of MCID by definition. As far as the improvement in strength, whether it's grading strength based off out of five scale or by the gait, we do document for each patient the strength out of five and it seems that the patients do improve. Our study did not look at hip abduction strength improvement. And I think from your paper, a lot of these are partial thickness tears, I think is right. That's a good thing, yeah. Yeah, so I don't wanna speak for the senior authors sitting here, but partial thickness tears are much more likely to undergo endoscopic repair in his hands than full thickness tears. All right, this next question's for Dr. Maldonado. In terms of looking at your label reconstructions, did you separate the partial or the segmental repairs or reconstructions compared to the complete reconstructions and do those patients still have the similar outcome to those undergoing primary repair? For this study, we didn't do that, but that's a topic that we have studied in the past, comparing label reconstruction, segmental and circumferential. And we found that you can customize the reconstruction to the site of the defect. So either way is fine. And then one more question there. So it looked like with label recon, about 25% of patients still fail to reach MCID or PAS. I think label recon sometimes is the holy grail of hip arthroscopy that we think everything's fine. What were the issues in those patients? Or why do you think so many patients still had pain even after the labrums excised and recon? Well, for me, label reconstruction is a great tool, but I'm the first one to say that it's not the holy grail, especially in revision surgery. You have so many reasons that a hip arthroscopy can fail and you cannot fix all those patients doing label reconstruction. That's one thing. Usually what I've seen is progression of arthritis is usually the problem with these patients. Okay, great. And then a few questions coming in for Dr. Safran. So in MarketScan, do you have availability to look at NSAID prescriptions? Certainly, NSAIDs have been a major role in decreasing the rate of HO with our typical hip arthroscopy. Do you have that data at all, or it's not something we can access? So you actually have access to the pharmaceutical claims, but it's just what you don't have is the timing relative to the surgery. So we didn't include that because we couldn't tell if they got it pre-op or post-op or when they got it post-op. And then another related question on HO, do you think capsular management plays a role? And this certainly isn't from your data, but closing the capsule versus leaving the capsule open, do you think that plays a role in HO? Well, a lot of people have talked about that. In reality, Udi Rath had looked at that and did not find that that affected heterotopic ossification. So the only study out there that I'm aware of that has looked at that specifically didn't show a difference. And then of those with HO, were those a diagnosis of HO or went on to surgery or a mix? Were they symptomatic or potentially asymptomatic just labeled as a diagnosis? So it was just labeled in the post-operative billing form, if you will. So it's unclear. As you know, in practice, we see a lot of patients that'll have some calcifications or rarely does it cause symptoms. Occasionally though, we do get patients with large HO and do need to take it out. They are symptomatic, but that's much less common than those that just have it notable on post-operative radiographs. Okay, perfect. Thanks guys for three great papers and we'll transition to the second part of our program here. So if we can have the speakers for the second part, I'll come up here. It'll speed our transition. So we're going to spend the rest of the hour on.
Video Summary
In this video, a panel of doctors and researchers discuss various topics related to hip arthroscopy. The first question revolves around gluteus repairs and the difficulty patients have in reaching Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PAS) compared to Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID). The second question asks about the expected improvements in strength after surgery. The next set of questions is for Dr. Maldonado, who discusses label reconstructions and whether partial or segmental repairs have similar outcomes to complete reconstructions. The panel also discusses why some patients still experience pain after labrum excision and reconstruction. Dr. Safran is then asked about NSAID prescriptions and their role in decreasing heterotopic ossification (HO). The topic of capsular management and its role in HO is also discussed. Finally, the panel touches on the diagnosis of HO and whether patients with the condition went on to have surgery or were just labeled as having the condition.
Asset Caption
Morgan Rice, MD; David Maldonado, MD; Marc Safran, MD
Keywords
hip arthroscopy
gluteus repairs
strength improvements
labrum excision
heterotopic ossification
×
Please select your language
1
English